Former Somali Ambassador to China, Awale Kullane says Somali government’s response to UN human rights experts focuses on procedure while avoiding the central question: why was Chief Justice Bashe Yusuf Ahmed removed?
An old courtroom proverb says: If the law is on your side, argue the law. If the facts are on your side, argue the facts. If neither is on your side, pound the table, the ambassador wrote. “The response issued by Hassan Sheikh Mohamud’s government to UN human rights experts appears to do precisely that,” he added.
In a 13-paragraph letter, the Somali government challenges the experts’ procedures, questions the composition of the bench and criticises the handling of the hearing. Yet it never addresses the most fundamental question: Why was Chief Justice Bashe Yusuf Ahmed removed from office?
Ambassador Kullane’s comment comes after the Somali government issued a formal response denouncing a statement by UN human rights experts concerning the removal of the Chief Justice.
On 10 November, UN experts strongly condemned what they described as the use of state power to unlawfully remove Chief Justice Bashe Yusuf Ahmed, raising serious concerns about judicial independence and the rule of law in Somalia.
As former Somali Ambassador Awale Kullane points out, the government’s own response raises more questions than it answers.
“It acknowledges that the UN experts first requested an emergency meeting. It then complains that the Chief Justice did not preside over the proceedings the following morning — after the government had already removed him from office,” Kullane said.
But what the government’s letter conspicuously fails to address is even more significant.
President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud’s Government Wrote Thirteen Paragraphs to the UN. Not One Says Why the Chief Justice Was Removed.
An old courtroom proverb says: if the law is on your side, argue the law; if the facts are, argue the facts; if neither, pound the table. The government’s reply to the UN human rights experts pounds the table. It complains about procedure, about the bench, about the hearing. It never reaches the charge.
Its own words undo it. It admits the experts asked for an emergency meeting first. It complains the Chief Justice did not preside, the morning after removing him.
What the reply leaves out says more. A Chief Justice removed without a stated reason. Troops at the Supreme Court. Judges stripped of protection. Travel bans. A replacement sworn in with the President watching. Not one is denied. Not one is explained.
Procedure is a shield. Silence on the soldiers is also an answer.
The rule of law is not proved by a letter to Geneva. It is proved when judges can enter their court without soldiers at the door.
@TheVillaSomalia @HassanSMohamud @Bashe_Ahmed
— Amb. Awale Kullane (@Awalekullane) November 15, 2026
“It offers no explanation for the removal of the Chief Justice. It does not account for the presence of armed troops at the Supreme Court. It does not explain why judges were stripped of their security protection, why travel restrictions were imposed, or why a replacement was sworn in in the presence of the President,” he added.
These are not minor procedural disagreements. They go to the heart of judicial independence and the constitutional order.
Somalia government disputes the process followed by the UN experts, but leaves the central allegations unanswered. It challenges the messenger while avoiding the substance of the message.
The UN experts stressed that judges must be able to perform their duties and make decisions independently, without political pressure, threats or interference from other branches of government.
The dispute has become particularly sensitive because Baashe’s removal took place just one night before the Supreme Court was expected to issue a ruling on a case challenging constitutional amendments and the extension of the terms of federal government institutions.
The case was filed by former Somali President Sheikh Sharif Sheikh Ahmed, who questioned the procedures used to amend the constitution and the legality of decisions concerning extensions of the terms of government institutions.
On November 5, five Supreme Court judges proceeded with hearings in the case and issued a ruling declaring the extensions of the president’s and parliament’s terms unconstitutional, stating that their respective mandates had expired.
The court also declared Baashe’s removal null and void, arguing that the president’s decision amounted to interference in a constitutional case already before the judiciary.
But former Ambassador Kullane notes that The rule of law is not demonstrated by sending a 13-paragraph letter to Geneva.
“It is demonstrated when judges can enter their own courtroom without armed soldiers at the door, when judicial decisions are free from political interference, and when no Chief Justice can be removed without a lawful and publicly stated reason,” he added.

